Show AWL words on this page.
Show sorted lists of these words.
|
This page continues the academic discussion skills section by looking at how to agree and disagree. There is also an example discussion to show how to use some of the phrases.
At university you will need to argue your point, in other words give your opinion on certain topics, with reasons and evidence. This academic 'argument' is different from ones you may have in everyday life. Although it may get heated, it will always be civilised and polite. It is important to remember this even when you disagree with another speaker's argument. In such cases, you should try to disagree politely, by first acknowledging their opinion before saying why you disagree. It is also possible to simply disagree, but you should avoid doing this too often as it may seem rude.
Phrases for agreeing, acknowledging someone else's idea, and disagreeing are shown in the language phrase box.
Agreeing
Acknowledging ideas
Disagreeing
Below is an example discussion on the topic of transportation in a particular city. There are three students involved. Phrases for agreeing, acknowledging ideas, and disagreeing are shown in bold.
Agreeing |
Disagreeing |
|
Acknowledging ideas |
Student A: I think that the transportation here is excellent,
because there are so many different options: bus, underground, taxi. I really love the buses here.
They run many different routes, and the cost is quite reasonable, under one pound for most of the places I go to.
What's your opinion?
Student B: I agree with you. The buses are very convenient and cheap.
And the subway is good too, it's not expensive at all.
Student C: That may be true, but you are only considering the cost. If we look at
how frequent the transport is, then it's not so good. For example I often have to wait twenty or thirty minutes for
a bus when I go to the university. It's really not convenient for me.
Student A: I really don't agree with you.
In my opinion the transport is extremely
convenient. As I just said, the buses run many different routes, so you can get anywhere in the city quite easily.
For instance I can take a bus from where I live to the university, or another one to the train station,
another to the football stadium. They'll all direct and I don't need to change.
Student B: So you mean that convenience in terms of destination is important in a good transportation system?
Student A: Yes, that's certainly one aspect. In terms of the buses, there are also the number of bus stops, which again makes them
very convenient.
Student B: Yes, I see.
Student C: I don't think I'd say that. In some ways, the more stops there are, the less convenient it is.
It makes the journey longer. And how about frequency? Isn't that important too?
Student A: Yes, in my opinion it is. But I don't have any problem with that. I never have to wait more than about ten minutes for a bus, so
in terms of frequency they are very convenient for me.
Student B: That's what I think too. I never have to wait long for a bus either.
It could be that you're just unlucky with where you live.
Student C: I take your point, but I still don't think I agree.
As far as I'm concerned
the transportation needs improving in many aspects, because it's just not good enough.
You mentioned taxis, but they're far too expensive. For example
I once took one to the train station in the evening, and I paid almost ten pounds.
Student A: I'm not so sure about that. Ten pounds to me seems quite reasonable for a taxi fare.
And isn't that just the nature of taxis? That they are more expensive?
Student C: I don't think so. I mean of course they should be more expensive than other forms of transportation, but not so expensive.
Student B: What do you mean by expensive? How much is too much?
Student C: I would say that two or three times as much as other forms of transport is fine, so maybe three pounds for a typical journey. Certainly
not as much as ten pounds!
Student B: I see. So what do suggest to improve the situation? Taxi drivers have to make a living, after all.
Student C: Well, I think what the local council should do is reduce the starting fare for taxis. That would at least make
them more economical for shorter distances. If the fare for longer distances is higher, it would equal things out. Alternatively...
Agreeing |
Disagreeing |
Acknowledging ideas |
Below is a checklist for this page. Use it to check your understanding.
Area | OK? | Notes/comment |
I know a range of phrases for agreeing in an academic discussion | ||
I know how to acknowledge ideas in a discussion to make disagreement more polite | ||
I know phrases for disagreeing in a discussion |
Read more about clarifying in the next section.
Go back to the previous section about asking for and giving opinions in discussions.
Author: Sheldon Smith ‖ Last modified: 09 September 2019.
Sheldon Smith is the founder and editor of EAPFoundation.com. He has been teaching English for Academic Purposes since 2004. Find out more about him in the about section and connect with him on Twitter, Facebook and LinkedIn.
1
2
3
4
5
6